From: Rick Anderson <[log in to unmask]>
Date: Tue, 18 Aug 2015 13:30:01 +0000

For those interested, there was some very good discussion of the Beall vs.
SciELO flap in the Scholarly Kitchen blog the other day, initiated by
Phill Jones of Digital Science:

http://scholarlykitchen.sspnet.org/2015/08/10/defending-regional-excellence-in-research-or-why-beall-is-wrong-about-scielo/

The comments string is particularly instructive, I think.

---
Rick Anderson
Assoc. Dean for Collections & Scholarly Communication
Marriott Library, University of Utah
Desk: (801) 587-9989
Cell: (801) 721-1687
[log in to unmask]




On 8/17/15, 11:49 PM, "LIBLICENSE" <[log in to unmask]> wrote:

>From: Kathleen Shearer <[log in to unmask]>
>Date: Mon, 17 Aug 2015 09:19:51 +0200
>
>Open Access in Latin America: A paragon for the rest of the world
>
>August 17, 2015
>
>Latin America is one of the world¹s most progressive regions in terms
>of open access and adoption of sustainable, cooperative models for
>disseminating research; models that ensure that researchers and
>citizens have access to the results of research conducted in their
>region.
>
>SciELO is a remarkable decentralized publishing platform harboring
>over 1,200 peer-reviewed journals from fifteen countries located in
>four continents - South America. Central-North America, Europe and
>Africa. Redalyc, based in Mexico, is another extraordinary system
>hosting almost 1,000 journals from fourteen Latin American countries
>plus Spain and Portugal. Governments around the world spend billions
>of dollars on infrastructure to support research excellence; platforms
>such as SciELO and Redalyc are extensions of this much larger
>investments in research. They reflect an enlightened understanding in
>Latin America that the wide dissemination of and access to research
>results is as important as the research itself. The rest of the world
>would do well to take note.
>
>In a recent blog post, these two initiatives were discredited by
>Jeffrey Beall. In the post, Beall compared the two publishing
>platforms to favelas, resulting in a mean-spirited insult to both
>favela dwellers on the one hand, and SciELO and Redalyc on the other.
>Rather than maligning these initiatives, they should be held up as
>examples of best practice for the rest of the world.
>
>Furthermore, just because some in North America do not know about
>SciELO and Redalyc does not render them irrelevant. This is an
>extremely elitist and narrow view of the world. Although these
>platforms may not be well known in some places, SciELO and Redalyc do
>raise the visibility and accessibility of the journals they host,
>particularly with their local communities. If these journals were
>published by the big commercial publishers, the vast majority of
>researchers in Latin America would simply not have access to the
>articles in those journals. What value is visibility, if people cannot
>access the articles?
>
>One of the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals, which were
>finalized on August 1, 2015, is to ³Build resilient infrastructure,
>promote inclusive and sustainable industrialization and foster
>innovation². Both Scielo and Redalyc are excellent exemplars of this
>type of infrastructure. These types of networked meta-publishers allow
>for central governance of policies, procedures and controls, but are
>intentionally decentralized to support the development of local
>capacity and infrastructure ensuring greater sustainability and
>alignment with local policies and priorities. What Beall advocates
>for, namely to let powerful foreign players come in and take over
>local capacity building, is exactly the opposite of what sustainable
>development is about.
>
>For these reasons, we believe that SciELO and Redalyc are very nice
>neighbourhoods indeed!
>
>Signed by,
>
>Juan Pablo Alperin, Public Knowledge Project and Simon Fraser University,
>Canada
>
>Dominique Babini, CLACSO, Argentina
>
>Leslie Chan, University of Toronto Scarborough, Canada
>
>Eve Gray, University of Cape Town, South Africa
>
>Jean-Claude Guédon, University of Montréal, Canada
>
>Heather Joseph, SPARC, United States
>
>Eloy Rodrigues, University of Minho, Portugal
>
>Kathleen Shearer, COAR, Canada/Germany
>
>Hebe Vessuri, Universidad Nacional Autonoma de Mexico and Instituto
>Patagónico de Ciencias Sociales y Humanas, Argentina