Hi Jordan,
You are on the right track of it being a case-by-case question of looking at each work on the recital/concert. I am not a lawyer, but I spent many years as a music librarian and have examined several different institutions’ takes on how
much risk they are willing to take on with their concert/recital recordings. There’s multiple layers to examine, and the level of risk varies as to how an institution justifies being able to make the recording to begin with and how widely they justify being
able to distribute that recording. In what I have seen, to openly stream recordings as you are exploring, the safest thing is to ensure that a) the underlying musical work is public domain, b) the edition/arrangement are public domain, and c) there is some
sort of agreement with the performers.
Here’s more details on those things:
- Mechanical rights: Performance license (like ASCAP and BMI) do not include the right to record a work at all. A mechanical license is needed from the rights holder if a work is under
copyright. Live-streaming of a concert (without making an on-demand stream or physical recording afterwards) can fall under the performance license/broadcast license if a campus has one. In practice, some schools of music will take the angle of justifying
the creation of a recording as fair use for educational use by the performers/teachers during class time or study time in the library. For theater performances, if a school rents scripts/scores (as is the case with most contemporary works), the right to create
one video recording from one-camera angle is often included for educational use when the school signs the agreement with the rights holder. In either of these cases, I have seen institutions use their local policies for creating and distributing Copyright
Section 108 preservation copies to guide how they handle the concert/recital recordings. In this, the institution’s definition of “library premises” comes into play on whether they stream at all or how widely they stream behind a login wall.
- Copyright status of work and arrangement: To deem a musical work to be public domain, you need to look at the copyright status of both the underlying musical work as well as the copyright
status of the particular edition of that musical work. For example, if your orchestra performed from a pre-1929 edition of Beethoven’s Symphony no. 9, that would be fine. Beethoven works are public domain and the older edition is also public domain. If the
orchestra performed the same work but with a 1929 or after edition, the editing of that score is likely subject to copyright and mechanical rights would need to be sought from the rights holder. Same logic follows with arrangements of works. Even if the original
work is a public domain folk song, the orchestration or arrangement likely has a copyright from the publisher/arranger.
- Rights of performers: Performers have rights to their performances. Professional record producers will use a work-for-hire scenario where the performers sign their rights over to the
entity creating the recording. Several schools of music will have students agree to some sort of statement at some point in their education saying that their performances are able to be used by the school. Guest artists or other non-school clinicians who visit
campus also have rights and permissions need to be acquired from them (or included in their guest artist agreement) to allow both creating and distributing a recording.
Again, there’s a wide range of how much risk an institution is willing to take. But public domain works, public domain editions, and performer agreements are the safest route to facilitate open streaming.
Cheers,
Rachel
Rachel Fox Von Swearingen
Collections Lead Librarian
Syracuse University Libraries
315.443.9779
[log in to unmask]
222 Waverly Ave., Syracuse, NY 13244
syracuse.edu
Syracuse University
From: Jordan Ruud <[log in to unmask]>
Date: Fri, 15 Mar 2024 15:52:11 +0000
Greetings all – I’m fairly new to this side of things and wanted to run a question by those with more experience in licensing. Our music faculty have concert recordings that they’d
like to deposit in our institutional repository, which is publicly accessible. I’m not entirely sure about the permissibility of this under our campus licenses with ASCAP and BMI (which I assume are fairly standard licenses).
From experience, is depositing records like this generally permitted, or (my fear) is it a case-by-case question of determining the ownership of each composition in a concert recording
to identify which can or can’t be deposited?
Thanks and happy Friday,
Jordan Ruud
Interim Director and Collection Development Librarian, Boreham Library, University of Arkansas – Fort Smith
[log in to unmask]